The Mississippian Spade

by Jeffery Steiner, Plymouth, Wisconsin

Large Mississippian Mill Creek chert spade from the Wickliffe Mounds cache in Ballard County, Kentucky, showing finely flaked workmanship.

Spade found in a cache near Wickliffe Mounds, in Ballard County, Kentucky. It is one of eleven found buried together, and was never utilized, as it shows no polish. It is made from Mill Creek chert and measures a fraction more than 12 inches in length. Collection of the author.

Mississippian spades are very interesting, large stone tools crafted by Mississippian artisans mainly for the purpose of digging and loosening soil for farming of corn and other crops of the time period. Hoes and spades increased productivity, allowing for the planting of extensive fields of crops such as corn. This in turn, led to more available food for those living in Mississippian villages. Certainly other uses would have been the digging of cache pits, storage pits, graves, or grubbing for roots. The spade was also a tool to soften the earth and soil for filling baskets of dirt for the mound building process.

The crops were generally tended by women of the society. The fields of the Mississippian Indians looked quite different from those we see today; beans, corn, squash, and other crops grew alongside each other. This was an efficient use of land because the corn stalks would provide shade for the lower crops and acted as supports or stakes for the beans to wind around.

Spades were made out of a variety of cherts such as Burlington, Kaolin, Crescent, and La Moine. Chert and limestone are found in the Cahokia area. In southern Illinois, Mounds and Dongola chert were used. On the outlying area of the Mississippian occupation, less desirable material like sandstone, limestone, and certain igneous and metamorphic materials were used. Note that all of these materials combined only accounted for about three percent of all known hoes and spades.

The two cherts that were most commonly used are 1. Dover chert, which is found near Stewart County, Tennessee, and 2. Mill Creek chert, the quarry being located in Union County, Illinois. More spades were made from Mill Creek chert than any other material. It is a tabular chert and one of the toughest cherts around, precisely why Mississippian agriculturists prized it. A weak chert would chip when used in the soil. Heat treated chert would chip easily, so raw Mill Creek, which was found in thinner, flatter nodules, was preferred. This raw material was so desired that some of the open pits were dug to a depth of 10-20 feet and a width from 12-40 feet. Mill Creek is found in slabs from two to five inches thick and up to two feet long and one foot wide. This made it ideal for use in the manufacturing of larger flint items. It is well known that Mississippian sites are near the present surface, so the cultivation and plowing of modern farm fields brought these large chert implements to the surface.

Spades and hoes were found in large numbers in the late 1800s and early 1900s. Their large size and shiny bits made them easy to find in fields where the early collectors and curious farmers picked them up.

Spades were found over a large area covering 200,000 square miles. Most spades were recovered in the Illinois and Missouri counties nearest to Cahokia. They have also been found as far north as the Aztalan area of southern Wisconsin. Some have been found in eastern Ohio and west to eastern Oklahoma. Spades have been found usually one at a time, rarely in a cache or large group. There are many documented caches, with the largest containing 50 notched hoes and 25 spades. The type of spades found would have a highly polished bit from use as though a coating of clear nail polish has been applied.

The polished surface is caused from the cutting of plants that form a buildup of a material called Opal Phytolith. Certain other spades show no use at all. The corn and other crops produced with these tools fed many thousands of people for well over two hundred years. One should never underestimate the ingenuity of ancient man for the invention of these unique and fascinating artifacts, because they helped immensely with the livelihood of their culture.

Flared-bit Mississippian spade made from colorful Mill Creek chert, found near Dyersburg in Crittenden County, Kentucky, with use polish along the cutting edge.

Above: A flair-Bit style spade made from a highly colorful Mill Creek chert. It was found by Mark Harris near the town of Dyersburg in Crittenden County, Kentucky. It has a high polish that extends just along the edge of the bit. It measures 9 1/4 inches in length.

Below: An extremely large Mill Creek chert spade measuring 13 3/4 inches in length, found in Livingston County, Kentucky, by Raleigh Johnson

Extremely large Mississippian spade made from Mill Creek chert, measuring 13¾ inches long and found in Livingston County, Kentucky, by Raleigh Johnson.

.

Chocolate Dover chert Mississippian spade (left) and gray Dover chert Mississippian spade (right), both large prehistoric agricultural tools from Tennessee.

Dover Spades – Above left: A “paddle” style spade made from a chocolate Dover chert. It exhibits a near glass-like high polish over nearly half of its surface, which measures 8 inches in length. It was found on the Ledbetter Site in Livingston County, Kentucky. Above right: A V-shaped spade of grey Dover chert found in Montgomery County, Tennessee. It too has high bit polish and also measures 8 inches in length.

Large Mississippian spade made from Mill Creek chert, recovered from the Wickliffe Mounds cache in Ballard County, Kentucky. The 11⅞-inch spade shows no evidence of use polish.

Dr. Michael Gramly wrote the definitive work on the Dover quarry, Prehistoric Lithic Industry at Dover, Tennessee, published in 1992. The back of the book featured a large spade found in the archaeological excavations at the site. In the picture above, the actual quarry site is behind the group that Dr. Gramly is speaking to. As one walks the site, large pieces of flint are everywhere. Some of the nodules are incredibly large, which would have been necessary in spade manufacturing. The Mississippians rolled the nodules quite a distance down the valley to sites where stone knappers lived and manufactured a wide variety of tools. It was obviously a large scale operation, since the ground was covered with debitage more than four feet deep in places.

Large Mississippian spade made from Mill Creek chert, recovered from the Wickliffe Mounds cache in Ballard County, Kentucky. The 11⅞-inch spade shows no evidence of use polish.

A second spade from the cache found near Wickliffe Mounds, in Ballard County, Kentucky. It too shows no use polish, is made from Mill Creek chert and measures 11 7/8 inches in length.

References

Central States Archaeological Journal, 2004, Volume 51.4, pages 142-144.

Central States Archaeological Journal, 2001, Volume 58.4, page 218.

Lithic Casting Lab.

Megalithics / Flintknapper.


Membership Application
Officers and Societies
Calendar of Events

Acquiring a Masterpiece

by Mike Sutton, Harrisburg, Illinois

Central States Archaeological Societies 2010 April Journal


Johnson County Illinois Ramey knife made of heat-treated Mill Creek chert prehistoric lithic blade
Johnson County Illinois Ramey knife made of heat-treated Mill Creek chert prehistoric lithic blade

When moons and planets synchronize into alignment, karma can peer over a collector’s shoulder and smile. Something extraordinary may be seeking a long tenure in his cabinet.

Premium artifacts with solid documentation are quite elusive.and opportunities to acquire can be rare. If a serious collector gets the chance to secure a genuine, recently discovered, top shelf piece for his collection, he should make the deal and record every bit of information on the artifact he can possibly obtain. It’s an important and critical imperative for all interested in preserving the past.

An unlikely person instilled this belief in me. A local rock hunter had made the “find of a life-time” when he discovered an exquisite Ramey knife just east of the small village of Cypress, in southern Illinois. He was a tenacious surface hunter, but bass fishing was his first love. He decided he needed anew bass boat, so he decided to part with the blade. I considered the piece to be an important example of southern Illinois lithic art, and desperately wanted it. But it was the mid 1980’s, the country was just coming out of a recession, and the blade was beyond reach for me, or so I thought.

Indeed, I was now the proud new caretaker of the flawless Johnson County Ramey knife, appropriately wrought from heat-treated Mill Creek chert. I frequently pulled the rock from its place of safe keeping, and meticulously examined it, to assure myself that I actually owned the thing. Yes, itwasn’t just a fantastic dream, I had really acquired the blade, and oh, what a fine and perfect specimen it was. A mother knew precisely what a son’s novice collection needed.

large prehistoric hornstone blade Crittenden County Kentucky bi-pointed flint blade with banding
Massive hornstone blade from Crittenden County, Kentucky, noted for its striking banding and exceptional craftsmanship.

Several months passed, and one Sunday in August in the late 1980’s, I attended the summer rockshow at the Executive Inn in Owensboro,Kentucky. As I entered, remarkable thing was happening. A noticeably excited, but small band of people were working their way around the room; stopping tochat, gaining and losing members as it meandered around the expansive room’s perimeter. Eventually, as I continued to visit with fellow collectors and displayers, I made my way closer and closer to the group to see what was causing all the fuss.

Three collectors from Crittenden Co., Ky., were commanding all the attention. As I came to within a few feet of the commotion, I noticed that the leader of the clan was pulling something from an old, wrinkled, paper sack to the thrill and elation of everyone that huddled around. As my curiosity morphed into anxiety, I continued to chat with a friend, while paying close attention from the corner of one eye. In and out, the mysterious article would flash to the sounds of approval as the group leader would permit brief glances to those who wanted a peek.

Then at long last, as the men ever so slowly approached, I made eye contact with the one who held the tattered bag. With an inquisitive glance, I raised my eyebrows as if to ask? “Can I see?” Without hesitation he pulled his treasure just half way from the bag as if it might escape when fully exposed.

For the next few seconds, I peered at one of the most striking examples of lithic art I had ever seen. Protruding from the old sack was a drop dead, killerof a hornstone blade that was so superb, it literally took my breath. Although the paper bag concealed its lower half, the piece looked to be a foot long. Its dark blue-gray flint and bi-pointed profile was not unlike the Benton blades from northern Mississippi that have been found in caches and associated with turkeytails. Its most, notable feature was the elongated, concentric banding that rippled through the blade’s matrix and curved across its face. The sheer beauty of the material, coupled with the excitement of the moment, seared the experience into my mind. As the years pass, I will have the luxury of revisiting the memory again and again, as it was a thrilling moment in time I will not soon forget.

Even today, thinking back to that very afternoon, the image of the blade and the wrinkly bag is still vivid in my head. The contrasting images are paradoxical, indeed! I was struck by the profound in-fluence material can play in the perception and the reality of aesthetics. I found it hard to comprehend that the blade in the sack had been crafted from the beautifully exquisite material. The nodule it was made from must have been enormous and quite valuable.

That day at Owensboro, those sharing the blade had an impressive story to tell. The men had uncovered their extraordinary find the day before that very Sunday. Swollen with pride, they were compelled to show it off to anyone who would share their excitement, and Owensboro was the perfect venue to exhibit the trophy.

According to the blade’s owner, it had been uncovered in the deep back woods of Crittenden County Kentucky, somewhere between Marion and Tolu and in close proximity to the Ohio River. Without a doubt, it was a huge piece of finely worked flint.The excitement they must have felt, as the rock was uncovered is an emotion all artifact hunters relish, but few experience. A pristine blade that had lain undisturbed for thousands of years. It would become an object of adoration for all who experienced it.

close up prehistoric flint blade banding hornstone concentric patterns lithic detail
Close-up showing the elongated, concentric banding that defines the blade’s visual impact.

A couple of years later, I learned that Chalmer Lynch, the old time collector/dealer of Evansville, Indiana fame, had purchased the remarkable find shortly after my encounter at the Kentucky. Show. In 1990, Chalmer was fast approaching one hundred years of age, and one by one, the old gentleman was selling off the cream of his personal collection. The instant I learned that the blade was for sale, I contacted the Mr. Lynch to tell him I was interested, but was informed that I may have called too late. Another collector had tried to acquire the piece, but didn’t have quite enough cash to close the deal. Chalmer wouldn’t take the guy’s shotgun to make up the difference. I was told that the guy had two weeks to come up with the money, and if he didn’t, the blade was mine.

He didn’t and fourteen days later this lithic masterpiece was crossing the Wabash to its new home in Illinois.

Membership Application
Officers and Societies
Calendar of Events