Paleo Period Points of the Carolina Piedmont

by Ron L. Harris, Hickory, North Carolina

Collection of Paleo-Indian projectile points from North Carolina assembled over 55 years by Ron L. Harris.

At top: The author’s entire North Carolina Paleo collection assembled over a 55-year span.

The earliest prehistoric human occupation in North Carolina dates to the Paleo-Indian period, which is thought to have begun around 10,000 BC. The temporal marker for that period is the fluted projectile point usually recovered as a surface find on exposed surfaces such as plowed fields, road cuts, construction sites and eroding streams or fields.

Archaeologists recognize two main cultures within the Paleo-Indian period in the North Carolina Piedmont region. They are Clovis & Hardaway-Dalton.

The Clovis Culture made beautiful distinctive fluted spear points (9500 – 8500 BC) that show remarkable similarities across the American continent. The purpose of the Clovis flute or channel most likely was to facilitate the hafting process. The edges on both sides near the base were dulled, so as to prevent them from cutting through the bindings that attached the point to the spear shaft. It should be noted that as of yet no Clovis points have been excavated from an undisturbed stratified site or found in context with datable material in N.C.

Late Paleo Hardaway-Dalton projectile point made from rhyolite found in Randolph County, North Carolina.

Hardaway-Dalton point: This late-Paleo Hardaway-Dalton point is made of porphyritic Rhyolite. It was recovered in the Cedar Square community near Randleman in northern Randolph County, North Carolina. Size: 3 inches. Collection of the author.

The Hardaway-Dalton Culture made differently styled spear points with shallow indentations on each side of the blade near the basally thinned base with ground (dulled) proximal blade edges (8500 – 8000 BC).

Another projectile point type that figures into the Paleo-Indian time frame in the N.C. Piedmont is the Alamance point. It is believed to be a variant or sub-type of the Hardaway-Dalton with both occurring in the same time frame.

Infrequently, Simpson type points of the late Paleo period are found in the lower N.C. Piedmont regions. However, this type is usually found in the Deep South such as Florida and South Georgia. Fluting for the Simpson point is absent or weak but basal areas are ground. The hafting area is constricted or “waisted”.

Spears tipped with these unique types of stone points were the main hunting tools in the Paleo-Indian time frame.

Below At right: An exceptionally well made fluted point found in the Blue Ridge mountains of Alleghany County, North Carolina in the New River drainage. Made of high-grade golden-tan flint. Size: Just under 4 inches. Collection of the author.

Exceptionally well-made fluted point from Alleghany County and a Late Paleo Alamance point from Moore County, North Carolina.

Above on the left: A late Paleo Alamance point found in Moore County, N.C. in the Cape Fear River drainage. It is highly patinated Silicified shale. Note the fluted or thinned base. Size: 1 1/2 inches. Collection of the author.

These First Carolinians were nomadic hunters & gatherers who moved regularly through vast territories on a seasonal basis in search of new resources. They lived in small family groups that archaeologists call bands. Subsistence comes from the hunting and gathering of wild foods. They carried or pulled all of their possessions from one location to another and therefore built no permanent dwellings. Protection from severe weather consisted of temporary shelters constructed from sticks and brush, forest thickets or the occasional rock shelter. Clothing and mats were likely from plant fibers and animal hides. Containers may have included bark and/or animal bags, gourds and woven nets from vines or grass.

The most important excavated N.C. site yielding Paleo-Indian components is the Hardaway Site (31-ST-4) on the west bank of the Yadkin River near the town of Badin in Stanly County, N.C. The Hardaway site investigations formed the basis of Paleo-Indian and Early Archaic sequences for the Carolina Piedmont as defined by Joffre L. Coe (1964).

The classic fluted Clovis point was not recovered from Hardaway; however, it is thought by archaeologists to be contemporary with the Hardaway phase, which represents the earliest occupation at the site and dates to at least 8000 BC (Ward 1983).

The Hardaway Corner-Notch projectile point evolved from the Hardaway-Dalton. It is smaller with “U” shaped corner-notches. Archaeologists consider this particular type to be the beginning of the Early Archaic period in N.C. dating to about 8000 BC.

Some archaeologists think the earliest Paleo-Indians lived mostly in the Piedmont because more fluted points have turned up there than elsewhere in the state. The Piedmont was probably a more climate hospitable region to live in as opposed to the colder mountains.

Paleo-Indian sites on the low-lying Coastal Plain may presently be invisible, having been inundated by rising sea levels or deeply buried in floodplain soils. Widely scattered Paleo-Indian artifacts of the Clovis-Hardaway-Dalton types have been found in the mountains and foothills of North Carolina but presently no significant undisturbed locations for this period exist there either. This may be due in part to these First Carolinians favoring hilltops or ridges for their camps. This allowed centuries of rain and weather to erode and wash away their sites.

Most of the Paleo-Indian type spear points seem to be produced from local lithic material leading archaeologists to conclude these ancient points were manufactured by resident Native Americans and not simply lost by seasonal hunting parties from outside (Purrington 1983). In the N.C. Piedmont this preferred raw material consisted of high-quality metavolcanic rocks found in the Slate Belt. Most stone tools found in the Piedmont that date to the Paleo-Indian period, as well as later periods, were made from this fine-grained, metamorphosed volcanic rock called rhyolite. Rhyolite outcrops are restricted to the area of the Slate Belt in and around the Uwharrie Mountains of Stanly & Montgomery Counties in south-central N.C.

It is not by accident that the site of the most important Paleo-Indian and Early Archaic search in N.C. – The Hardaway Site – also is located in the Uwharrie Mountains.

Rare Simpson Paleo-Indian point made from rhyolite recovered in Chatham County, North Carolina.

Simpson point: Simpson type Paleo point found in Chatham County, North Carolina in the Cape Fear River drainage. Short flutes or basal thinning on both sides. Rare type for N.C. in that this type is usually found in the deep-south region. However, this point is made from Rhyolite material indigenous to central N.C. where the point was recovered. Size: 3 1/2 inches. Collection of the author.

Rodney Peck, president of the Piedmont Archaeology Society of Virginia and the Carolinas, has undertaken the monumental task of recording fluted points found in North Carolina. This has been an ongoing task for many years and hundreds of fluted points have officially been recorded and are still being recorded in his survey.

Accompanying this article are several photographs illustrating examples of various Paleo-Indian projectile point types (Clovis, Hardaway-Dalton, Alamance & Simpson) typically recovered in the Piedmont and Blue Ridge foothills regions of North Carolina.

Rare clear quartz crystal fluted Paleo-Indian point from Alexander County, North Carolina.

Quartz point: Very rare clear quartz crystal fluted point found by Blake Deal in the Brushy Mountain community of “Vashti” of northern Alexander County, North Carolina. Size: 2 inches. Collection of the author.

References

Joffre L. Coe
1964 Formative Cultures of the Carolina Piedmont

Research Laboratory of Archaeology,
2001 Intrigue of the Past University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Larry R. Clark
2002 Indians of Burke County & western North Carolina

Robert W. Keeler
1971- Archaeological Survey of Upper Catawba River Valley

H. Trawick Ward & R. P. Stephen Davis, Jr.
1999 Time Before History: The Archaeology of North Carolina

Robert Overstreet
2007 Overstreet’s Indian Arrowhead Guide # 10


Membership Application
Officers and Societies
Calendar of Events

Eastern Colorado: The Garden of Eden(s)

Figure 1. The 3.75-inch long Eden found by Shane Skulvik in Logan County, Colorado. It is made of Flattop Chalcedony.

by Tom Westfall, Sterling, Colorado

Central States Archaeological Journal January 2011

The Eden point is Paleoindian in origin and dates to around 9500–7600 BP. The type site is the Finley site, located in Sweetwater County, Wyoming. Other Eden sites have been discovered on the High Plains, but they are few and far between.

Eden points are considered some of the most beautiful and highly valued projectile points on the High Plains. In their unresharpened form, they are usually long and quite narrow, often made from the finest lithic materials available. These points exhibit very fine flaking to a medial ridge and have a diamond-shaped cross section.

This past year has witnessed the recovery of several nice Eden points. The first point (Figure 1) is a 3.75-inch-long Eden made of Flattop Chalcedony. This point was found by Shane Skulvik in Logan County, Colorado. There is a bit more “base” on this particular point, and several have suggested that it may be a particularly well-made Scottsbluff point similar to several found at the Finley site where both Scottsbluff and Eden points were discovered together.

Figure 2. The 2.25-inch long Eden found by Grayson Westfall in Logan County, Colorado. It is made from Knife River Flint.

My son, Grayson, found a Knife River Flint Eden point (Figure 2) in Logan County, Colorado. Knife River Flint, a lithic fairly scarce in Colorado, seems to have been favored by the aboriginal peoples for making these points. This example shows a lot of reworking and is 2.25 inches in length in its present condition. This point was found on a gravel bar on our farm along with a Scottsbluff point, two Alberta points, and a Cody ultra-thin knife.

Figure 3. The 4.25-inch long Eden found by Steve Juranek in Sedgwick County, Colorado. It is made from Knife River Flint.

Another Knife River Flint Eden point (Figure 3) was found in July 2010 by Steve Juranek in Sedgwick County, Colorado. It is 4.25 inches in length.

Generally speaking, the base/stem of an Eden point has been “ground in” and may be barely discernible. There is some speculation that very narrow Eden points have been reworked from wider points, though Job Taylor disputes this assumption. Based on his observations and examinations, Eden points appear to have only been resharpened on their tips.

Having examined a fair number of Eden points myself, I would agree with Taylor’s assertion. Furthermore, I believe that the diamond-shaped cross section made for a sturdy point that did not experience significant breakage when impacting bone or other hard substances. Most impact fractures on Eden points which I have seen have allowed for relatively easy “re-tipping.” In some cases, the tips were broken, but by removing just a few small flakes on either side of the fracture, the knapper created a serviceable point again.

Figure 4. A grouping of Eden points in the author’s collection. Materials include Niobrara Jasper (far left and far right), agatized wood, Knife River Flint, and agatized wood. The large point at the bottom is made of translucent agatized wood. The largest point is 3.5 inches long, and the smallest is 1.75 inches. Some examples (left side) may be described as “Eden-flaked” Scottsbluff points.

It is my suspicion that Scottsbluff, Alberta, Eden, and Firstview points were used somewhat interchangeably by ancient peoples. Differences may reflect personal preference, or further research may lead to a clearer understanding of how each style was most effectively used.

Membership Application
Officers and Societies
Calendar of Events

A Folsom Site in Eastern Colorado

by Tom C. Westfall, Sterling, Colorado

April 2015 Central States Archaeological Journal

Folsom site artifact assemblage from Kiowa County Colorado showing Folsom point fragments preforms Clovis Goshen and Midland projectile points on display
Entire lithic assemblage from the Kiowa County Folsom site in eastern Colorado, including Folsom point fragments, preforms, and tools made from multiple Plains lithic materials.

The 1950’s were a time of mild winters, little precipitation, and hard winds in eastern Colorado. During that time, literally hundreds of thousands of prehistoric artifacts were recovered by a number of collectors. Many of these collectors have since passed on, and much of the information that accompanied the stones they assembled has been lost as well. This report is written to provide as much information as possible about a Folsom site in Kiowa County, Colorado, near the town of Brandon on the south side of the Big Sandy River. This assemblage was collected by Jerry Chubbuck, a well-known artifact enthusiast over a period of several years in the early 1950’s. The eroded field was put back into the soil conservation bank and no additional artifacts were recovered on the site.

A total of 60 point fragments and preforms were found on this small site. A multi-component site, several cultures are represented, including: Clovis (n=8); Goshen (n=6); Midland (n=3); and Folsom (n=43). In the Folsom component there are 11 pieces which appear to be preforms which were broken in manufacturing, a channel flake that was utilized as a bi-pointed graver, a scraper and 30 Folsom point fragments.

Lithic materials would suggest that the people who inhabited this campsite came from the south (or had well-developed trade) as Alibates dolomite (n=16) and Edwards Plateau chert (n=28) dominate the assemblage. Additional materials include quartz crystal (n=2), Narbona Pass chert (n=2), Tecovas jasper (n=1), Trout Creek jasper (n=3), Black Forest wood (n=5), Flattop chalcedony (n=1) and Smoky Hills jasper (n=2).

According to Jerry Chubbuck, this site was on the south side of the Big Sandy River and was a discrete campsite that contained only the material shown here. Other sites nearby included later components, but the “Folsom site” as Jerry called it, was a relatively small area, not much more than three acres. (Chubbuck, personal correspondence, 2000-2014).

Reworked Folsom point bases showing straight edge retouch from broken Folsom projectile points eastern Colorado Paleoindian tools
Two images showing the distinctive straight-edge reworking along the distal break of several Folsom point bases, suggesting reuse of broken points for specialized tools.

One of the most interesting features of this assemblage is the Folsom fragments (proximal portions/bases). Each of these pieces has been reworked along the distal break in a straight line, suggesting that these pieces were used subsequent to their initial break for some specialized purpose. Although Folsom “scrapers” made from salvaged points have been found in Folsom campsites, these pieces really don’t appear to be used in that manner. A number of “Plains archaeologists” have been consulted and as of this writing, no one has been able to identify this particular tool nor have similar tools shown up in other assemblages.

Another interesting piece in this assemblage is a salvaged channel flake. This channel flake is 27.1 mm in length, 3.5 mm in width and .051 mm thick. It has been flaked into a bi-pointed tool of some type, most likely a graver.

Alibates chert channel flake modified into a bi pointed graver Paleoindian lithic tool from Colorado Folsom site
Channel flake of Alibates chert worked into a bi-pointed graver tool.

It is highly likely that additional Folsom material exists on the Kiowa County Folsom site.

References

Chubbuck, Jerry
2000–2014 Personal correspondence.

Best Christmas Ever

by Rodney Farr, Canton, Missouri

January 2016 Central States Archaeological Journal

Folsom Paleoindian Fluted Projectile Point Found Christmas Day 1985 Missouri
Both faces of a finely fluted Folsom projectile point discovered by Rodney Farr near Canton, Missouri on Christmas Day, 1985.

In the fall of the year I used to run a small trap line. No matter what the weather, traps need to be checked every day. On Christmas Day, 1985, I went to check my traps early in the morning so I could be home for our annual family dinner. The weather was warm for December and the ground was muddy, so I had to park my car a long way from my traps.

On the way back to my car, I took a short cut across a farm field where I normally hunt for arrowheads. As I stepped across a little washout area in the field I looked down and saw this beautiful point lying fully exposed on the ground. It was a Folsom (Fig. 1).

The Folsom is a small to medium size, very thin, high quality fluted point with well contracted pointed auricles and a concave base. The fluting usually extends the entire length of each face. The blade flaking is extremely fine and the hafting area is ground. This is a very rare type, even in the area of highest incidence. They have been found in association with extinct bison remains 9000 B.C. to 8000 B.C.

The first of October 2015, I was at a farm auction in northern Lewis County, Missouri. I purchased a box that contained thirty Central States Archaeological Journals from 1956 to 1964. I’ve been a member of GSLAS for years and I have been buying up the old journals because they are a great source of information.

On the back cover “table of contents” of the first one I opened, I noticed “Fluted Points” by Paul V. Sellers of Lewistown, Missouri. Paul’s article talked of fluted points found along the Mississippi River near LaGrange and up to Canton.

A few years ago Dr. Julie Morrow from Arkansas State University met me in Hannibal and recorded my point in the “Paleo Point Data Base” for the Missouri Archaeological Society.

Measurements of the point:

Total length: 47.8 mm
Flute length side A: 37.2 mm
Flute length side B: 38.0 mm
Max thickness: 3.3 mm
Max inter-flute thickness: 2.7 mm

I’m not sure which is more amazing to me; that this point survived for thousands of years or that because of a little mud, I had the best Christmas ever.


References

Overstreet, Robert
2001 The Overstreet Indian Arrowheads Identification and Price Guide, 7th Edition

Sellers, Paul V.
1956 Fluted Points, Central States Archaeological Journal Vol. 2, No. 3, Pages 112–113

A Virginia Folsom Point?

Howard Boney

Volume 69, Number 1, January 2022 Central States Archaeological Journal

Virginia Folsom projectile point fragment, Paleoindian fluted point made of multicolored chert with red and cream mottling, side view showing basal thinning and flake scars, displayed with centimeter scale, featured in Central States Archaeological Journal.
Virginia Folsom fluted projectile point fragment, Paleoindian artifact made of multicolored chert with red, tan, and gray mottling, reverse view showing flake scars and thinning flakes, displayed with centimeter scale, featured in Central States Archaeological Journal. January 2022

A rare find for Virginia, this classic Folsom point was found in Southampton County, Virginia on December 5, 1991, by Jimmy Boney, brother of Howard Boney. He was out hunting, and while tracking a deer he spotted the point in a fresh deer track. Unfortunately, one ear is broken off. It is a fresh break and was no doubt broken when the deer stepped on it. It is too bad he didn’t search for the broken off piece, although it is very small. The material resembles jasper but may be a form of local chert. It is very colorful and has a remnant of the striking nipple at the base. Additionally, the point has the classic Folsom stubby appearance. It is 1½” x 7/8” wide.

Virginia Folsom fluted projectile point fragment, Paleoindian artifact made of multicolored chert with red, tan, and gray mottling, shown in hand for size comparison, illustrating small fluted point section from Virginia, featured in Central States Archaeological Journal.

THE MYSTERY OF THE MASTERPIECE

Journal Volume 36, Number 2, April 1989

JAMES MADDOX
Niantic, Illinois

Since time began, there has been an extremely rare group of people who have a special gift—the gift to listen to the stirring of a soul and the ability to transform that into something tangible. Anyone who has ever looked at a genuine Rembrandt or Charles M. Russell painting will know what I mean. This special gift might also be seen in a building by Frank Lloyd Wright, or in the English-designed Spitfire airplane of World War II. This gift can emerge in a variety of forms in all ages.

I submit that some of the makers of fluted points had this gift. Most would seek the best stone. Some would go to great effort to produce a fine point, but there was an occasional artisan who would see more in a stone. He would first have to see it in his mind. Then he set such standards that he would not stop work until the stone he held matched that in his mind. Whether in stone or paint on canvas, a master’s work will speak for itself.

After viewing many fluted points, I believe the two points shown below meet the requirements to be called great works of art. By giving recognition to the work, we are in a sense, paying tribute to the spirit of the maker.

Fluted points from Fulton County, Illinois and La Salle County, Illinois. . From the collection of James Maddox, Niantic, Illinois.

Michigan Paleo and Bayport Chert

by Todd Walterspaugh, Galesburg, Michigan

Volume 57, Number 1, January 2010 Central States Archaeological Journal

Seven Paleo points found in the state of Michigan. All are of local cherts, and three are of Bayport Chert.

Pictured above are seven Paleo points found in the state of Michigan. All are of local cherts, and three are of Bayport Chert. Of all the lithic materials utilized by Michigan’s Na­tive Americans, it is perhaps the most beauti­ful and widely distributed. It is named for the Bayport Formation where it outcrops. It is primarily found in the Northeastern area of Southern Michigan. It is found as nodules or irregular blocks generally along the river banks. The main source for the material is in Saginaw Bay, near Bayport, in Huron Coun­ty.

It has a waxy to chalky texture and is gener­ally light brown to medium grey in color. The material is high in fossil content. It also in­cludes quartz, which can appear as either white clouds or in a bulls-eye pattern. Other minerals present in the material include hematite, li­monite and dolomite. Fossils present include sponge spicules, brachipods, bryozans and colony coral.

Bayport Chert was utilized by all prehistoric time periods from Paleo to Late Prehistoric. The dominant use was during the Early Archaic Period. It was also prominent in the Middle Woodland Period. Commonly seen in use for Thebes, Adena and Snyders style points. Bayport Chert was a largely distributed material. Native Americans used it in all of Michigan’s lower peninsula. Its use extended as far away as Central Indiana, northward into northwestern Ohio, and southwestern Ontario, Canada.”Used by Permission of the Author”