Seldom-Found Projectile Point from North Carolina’s Piedmont

Two Fountain Creek projectile points from Chatham County, North Carolina, shown above a centimeter and inch scale.

by Peter G. Murphy and Alice J. Murphy, St. Johns, Michigan

More than a hundred years of archaeological research and information garnered from well documented amateur collections have made it possible to identify and date many of the more distinctive projectile points found in North America. Over a thousand types have been described in journals and reference books. But other points, especially the less common types and those with transitional characteristics, present classification challenges even to the professional archaeologist. The two points in Fig. 1 present such a challenge. Of the 1,279 identifiable projectile points we surface-collected over a three-year period from 83 cultivated-field sites in six counties of North Carolina’s Piedmont, only two (Fig. 1) appeared to be of the Fountain Creek type first described in 1978 by Floyd Painter in The Chesopiean. He described the point as rare and estimated that fewer than 75 were known to have been found, mainly in southeastern Virginia and northeastern North Carolina.

Painter (1978) provided dimensional data for 24 examples of his proposed Fountain Creek type and illustrations of six points, but the illustrations are somewhat stylized drawings rather than photographs of actual points. Based largely on form, he believed Fountain Creek is related to, or a variant of, the Early Archaic Palmer type first described by Coe (1964) in North Carolina. In his guide to projectile points of Virginia and the Carolinas, Peck (1993) does not make reference to Fountain Creek points, but one of the three Palmer points he illustrates clearly resembles Painter’s Fountain Creek type. The same is true for one or two of the 21 Palmer points pictured in Barnard’s (1988) guide to Southeastern points.

Both of the points in Fig. 1 have Fountain Creek characteristics, but the point on the left, with the deep serrations, is most similar to Painter’s illustrations. Further, the two points in Fig. 1 are similar to six of the ten examples pictured in Overstreet (2011). Interestingly, Overstreet did not include Fountain Creek points in his 1st edition (1989), but by the 3rd edition (1993) four examples were pictured. Substantive information on the point is very limited and only a few other publications make any mention at all, among them Dragoo (1993) and Hranicky (2011). In the comprehensive survey of 30,164 identifiable North Carolina points reviewed by McReynolds (2005), Fountain Creek is not among the 35 recognized types.

The characteristics that define Fountain Creek points include 2–7 deep serrations or notches on each blade margin, a ground and slightly curved (convex) base, and length of 27–55 mm (Painter 1978). The width-to-length ratio of Fountain Creek points shown in Overstreet (2011) averages 1:2.3; our two examples average 1:2.4. The similarities between the two points in Fig. 1, found at a site in Chatham County, are somewhat subtle. Both have ground, rounded bases (unlike the straight or slightly concave bases of most Palmer points), blades with relatively straight, serrated edges, and both are made of the same type of metavolcanic stone with similar patination. The serrations are largely worn down on the smaller point.

Figure 1. Two Fountain Creek points from a site in Chatham County of the North Carolina Piedmont. The point on left is 45 mm long.


Although Painter perceived a connection between Fountain Creek and Palmer, Overstreet (2011) suggests a similarity with Kirk Stemmed points. As discussed in Murphy and Murphy (2012), Palmer and Kirk are sometimes considered to be elements of an Early Archaic complex of point types, rather than distinct entities, although Palmer is considered the earlier of the two types. The site from which we collected the points in Fig. 1 yielded a wide variety of Archaic Period points, including Palmer and Kirk. If Fountain Creek points are indeed of the Early Archaic Period, they would fall within the age range of approximately 10,000–7,000 B.P. But we have seen no record of them being found in controlled excavations with actual evidence of age or relationships to other point types. Coe (1964) shows one point with Fountain Creek traits among a group of excavated Palmers, but he represents it as just another Palmer. His Palmer points tend to fall into two basic categories; those that are fairly broad relative to their length (width-to-length ratio 1:1.3) and those that are more slender (width-to-length ratio 1:2.3). Relative to Palmer, the 24 Fountain Creek points described by Painter (1978) tend to be intermediate (1:1.8) in width-to-length ratio.

Until good examples of Fountain Creek points are found in controlled excavations of stratified sites, their age and relationship to other points, such as Palmer or Kirk, will remain speculative. Painter’s (1978) suggestion of a relationship with Palmer appears entirely valid. The points share characteristics that can make it difficult to distinguish between the two and they occur in the same region. However, until further evidence is acquired it may be most reasonable to consider Fountain Creek points as components of a Palmer-Kirk complex. It remains to be seen whether they deserve to be recognized as a separate type rather than a variant of a more established type. Whatever the case, points of the form shown in Fig. 1 are uncommon even in their apparent main region of occurrence, Virginia and North Carolina. They present engaging questions concerning their proper classification relative to other points of the Southeast.

References

Barnard, Frank K.
1988. How to Find and Identify Arrowheads and Other Indian Artifacts (Southeastern United States). F.K. Barnard, Rt. 6, Box 511, Chapel Hill, North Carolina. 53 pgs.

Coe, Joffre L.
1964. The Formative Cultures of the Carolina Piedmont. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society New Series 54(5). 130 pgs.

Dragoo, Don W.
1993. Projectile Points of the Archaic Period, Eastern North America. Institute for Human History, Gloucester, Virginia. 36 pgs.

Hranicky, Wm Jack
2011. Prehistoric Projectile Points Found Along the Atlantic Coastal Plain. Universal Publishers, Boca Raton, Florida. 282 pgs.

McReynolds, Theresa E.
2005. Spatial and Temporal Patterning in the Distribution of North Carolina Projectile Points. North Carolina Archaeology 54:1-33.

Murphy Peter G. and Alice J. Murphy
2012. Palmer Points Reflect On-Going Change in the Early Archaic Southeast and Demonstrate the Complexities Inherent in Point Classification. Central States Archaeological Journal 59(3):149-151.

Overstreet, Robert M.
2011. Official Overstreet Identification and Price Guide to Indian Arrowheads. House of Collectibles. 1264 pgs.

Painter, Floyd
1978. The Fountain Creek Projectile Point. The Chesopiean 16(1-3):32-33.

Peck, Rodney M.
1993. Indian Projectile Point Types from Virginia and the Carolinas. Piedmont Archaeological Society of N.C. and S.C., Inc., 2121 Quail Drive, Harrisburg, North Carolina. 43 pgs.

George D. Burns, Sr. & Jr.: “The Other Story”

by Kevin G. Pipes, Dandridge, Tennessee

July 2016 Central States Archaeological Journal

Mississippian discoidal chunkey stone from Sevier County Tennessee labeled “Geo. Barnes Sevier Co. 1941,” a polished Native American stone game piece used in the prehistoric chunkey game.
The George Barnes discoidal found in Sevier County, Tennessee, in 1941.

Each night, I enjoy reading before sleep. I had just finished the latest Star Wars book and was still not quite ready for “lights out.” Scanning the stack of journals on my night stand, I decided to revisit the Central States Archaeological Journal, October, 2015 (Volume 62, #4).

I love this issue because it is full of great relics and interesting articles. One of those articles, “George D. Barnes, Sr. & Jr.: Relic Hunters of the 1900’s,” brought to mind a certain artifact from my own collection. It is a particularly nice discoidal which is labeled “George Barnes.” Unlike many of his relics, this labeling is not handwritten but is one of those plastic, embossed labels, so popular in the ’60s and ’70s.

Now, on to “The Other Story.” I acquired this discoidal in the early 2000’s from the collection of James Helms, who was the nephew of a World War I collector by the name of Hal Noe. Previously, I met Hal in the early 1980s after seeing his photo and collection in the Who’s Who in Indian Relics No. 4. I called him up and had a fantastic relic discussion that ended with Hal inviting me to visit his home and view his collection. During that first visit, the conversation eventually turned to George D. Barnes. I had often heard of Mr. Barnes while working summer jobs in the mid-1960s in Gatlinburg, Tennessee. Many people there remembered the “Barnes Cherokee Indian Museum.”

One of the discoidals in Hal’s collection bore the aforementioned name label of “George Barnes.” I asked Hal if it came from the museum. “No,” he said, “I bought it directly from George and it came with a very interesting tale.”

Artifact collector Kevin G. Pipes holding the Pigeon Forge Tennessee Mississippian discoidal chunkey stone in his relic room collection.
The author in his relic room holding the Pigeon Forge discoidal.

Hal related to me how Mr. Barnes first saw the discoidal on a farmer’s porch in Pigeon Forge being used to prop open his screen door. George was there asking permission of the farmer to look for relics in his field. The farm was located in the Pigeon River Valley on the fertile field in front of the farmer’s house stretched out to meet the river’s edge. It was there, the farmer had originally unearthed the discoidal while plowing his land with a team of mules.

When George asked to buy the disc, the farmer refused, as it “had a good use.” Several trips to the site of the farmer’s porch still resulted in the same result of “No thanks.” But George Barnes was quite a clever man and sensed that asking to pay for the disc might be giving the farmer the impression that it was valuable and one-of-a-kind. He hatched a plan and enlisted the help of the young nephew of a friend, a lad of about 12 or 13.

They traveled to Pigeon Forge from Gatlinburg, and George parked his car a short distance from the farmer’s house. He knew the farmer chose this time of day to sit on his porch and watch the river flow by. Handing the boy a “toe sack” (burlap bag) in which he had placed seven or eight discoidals of similar size, George instructed, “Wade into the river’s edge and walk downstream in front of the house. When you’re certain he’s watching you, stoop down and take up a rock similar in size to the discs. Act like you’re putting it in the toe sack, then move forward and do it again. When you’re finished, ease out of the river and go up and talk to the man sitting on his porch.”

“Don’t tell him what you’re looking for,” Barnes continued, “let him ask. Tell the farmer you like rocks and often wade the river looking for pretty ones. Then show him what’s in your toe sack, and comment on the disc laying on his porch. Pick it up and admire it and tell him how much you would like to have one like that for your collection. If he gives it to you, I’ll give you five dollars for it.”

Relic collector Hal Noe standing beside a display case of prehistoric artifacts and shell gorgets while holding a Native American effigy pipe.
Hal Noe and his discoidals as shown in Who’s Who in Indian Relics No. 4. The arrow points to the Pigeon Forge discoidal.

Hal’s story ended here, with the affirmation that George Barnes, Sr. and his young accomplice were successful in obtaining the discoidal. Much later, Hal purchased the relic from Barnes, needless to say, at a much higher price!

Artifact hunting always seems to come full circle, and I was privileged to hunt the same field where Barnes first met his farmer. I found several nice game stones, points, and several incised Mississippian pottery shards. The site was later destroyed when the city of Pigeon Forge built their wastewater plant, which “stinks” in more ways than one!

I stayed in touch with Hal Noe and, although I tried, I was never able to persuade him to sell me the discoidal in this story. After Hal’s passing in 1989, I met his nephew, James Helms, who inherited Hal’s collection. When James passed away, I enjoyed visiting his widow, Ann. She made the best ice tea, and we would sit and visit and talk about old times, sharing stories of Hal and James. Twenty years or so after listening to Hal relate “The Other Story,” Ann Helms sold me the discoidal and some other fine relics from Hal’s collection.

Relic collector Hal Noe standing beside a display case of prehistoric artifacts and shell gorgets while holding a Native American effigy pipe.
Another picture of the Hal Noe collection from Who’s Who in Indian Relics #4. He is shown standing and holding a fine stone effigy pipe next to a showcase full of shell gorgets.

If only relics could talk! The stories they could tell — from their origins, to the many hands they pass through. The very discoidal in this tale could have been used in “Chunkey Superbowl 50!”

A Remarkable Effigy Pipe from Georgia

by Olan Moore, Watkinsville, Georgia

Volume 71, Number 1, January 2024 Central States Archaeological Journal

As the Ogeechee River flows toward the Atlantic Ocean near Richmond Hill, Georgia, it forms a horseshoe bend around some shell middens. Over time the middens have eroded. It was along this edge of the river during the summer of 1977 that my friend, Bobby Morris and his wife Rita, were looking for shell beads. I had been with them on several occasions and finding four or five beads was a good day.

Mississippian human effigy pipe found near the Ogeechee River, Georgia in 1977, shown in four views, depicting a seated figure holding the pipe bowl; center image shows a Cat Serpent pottery effigy fragment from the same archaeological site.
Figure 1. The pipe, shown in four views, found near the Ogeechee River in 1977. It measures 1¾″ H x 3″ L. The diameter of the bowl is 1⅝″. At the center is a Cat Serpent pottery effigy, found near the same location as the pipe.

Bobby was searching near the river, and Rita was scouring above the bank when she discovered a pipe. She called to Bobby and said, “I found a pipe with a monkey on it!” (see Fig. 1). The following week I saw the pipe and realized it was an effigy pipe. Bert Bierer pictured a similar one in his Indian Artifacts in the Southeast: A Sketchbook on page 258. He described it as an effigy pipe — a human figure holding a bowl, which was found in the Hollywood Mound on the Savannah River in Georgia. Furthermore, he stated it was a ceremonial object of the Southeastern Ceremonial Complex, 400–800 years old.

To me, the figure resembles those made of marble from the Etowah Mounds of north Georgia.

It was also during the summer of 1977 that I found the incised human face (center – Fig. 1) near this same location. It is almost identical to the ones recovered by Clarence B. Moore on the Georgia coast in 189, and shown on pages 18 and 68 of his book on those expeditions.

References

Bierer, Bert W.
1977 Indian Artifacts in the Southwest: A Sketchbook. Privately published.

Moore, Clarence B.
1897 Certain Aboriginal Mounds of the Georgia Coast. Academy of Natural Science of Philadelphia.

The Thanksgiving Day Stick Man Cloud Blower Tube Pipe

by Stephen Langley, Soddy Daisy, Tennessee

Volume 70, Number 2, April 2023 Central States Archaeological Journal

Mississippian cloud blower tube pipe from Rhea County Tennessee engraved with stick-man effigy figures and decorative double rings around the center.
At top: Figures 1 and 2. Both faces of the cloud blower tube pipe. The pipe measures 6” in length and is shown full size.

I had made plans to go artifact hunting with my buddy, Stanley Thurman, on Thanksgiving Day in 1989. Stanley and I both worked at United Parcel Service. He was a package truck washer at the Athens, Tennessee UPS Center, and I came through Athens, Tennessee every night to pick up the Next Day Air packages and then transport them to the air facility in Knoxville, Tennessee. At the time, I was driving a semi-truck for UPS out of Chattanooga, Tennessee. Stanley and I shared a love for Indian artifacts and had become friends.

I had to work on the Wednesday night before Thanksgiving Day in 1989. When I got off from work on Thanksgiving morning, I hurried home. I was excited because Thanksgiving Day had always been my most productive day to look for artifacts.

When I arrived at my home, my wife met me at the door. She was pregnant with my son and suffering from morning sickness. So, I had to call my buddy Stanley and tell him that I couldn’t go artifact hunting that morning. I understood why my wife wanted me to stay at home that morning, but I was disappointed as would be expected.

Close-up of engraved stick-man effigy on Mississippian cloud blower tube pipe from Rhea County Tennessee showing human figure with arms at sides.
Figure 3. Close-up of the engraving at the top of the tube pipe showing a stylized human figure, possibly wearing a ritual mask.

When I called Stanley and gave him the bad news, he asked if I’d object if he took another friend of his, Charlie Moore, with him. I told Stanley that it would be OK with me. He then asked where I thought he and Charlie should hunt that morning. I told him where I had planned to hunt, and he called Charlie. Charlie Moore had never been artifact hunting, and Thanksgiving Day in 1989 was his first time to go.

Close-up engraving of dancing stick-man figure on Mississippian cloud blower tube pipe from Rhea County Tennessee with raised arms.
Figure 4. Close-up of the engraving at the bottom of the pipe depicting a figure with raised arms, possibly dancing.

My phone rang that morning at about 11 a.m. When I answered the phone, I heard Stanley’s excited voice on the other end and my heart sank. Stanley told me that Charlie had beginner’s luck and had found a beautiful cloud blower tube pipe with a stick man effigy engraved on it. Charlie found the pipe in the exact spot that I had suggested they hunt. Later on that afternoon, Stanley and Charlie brought the pipe to my home and let me see and hold it. I had hoped that Charlie would part with the pipe, but that was wishful thinking. For 23 years he kept the pipe locked up in a safe deposit box at his local bank. Then, in 2012, without my knowledge, he sold the pipe to another collector.

Decorative double rings with cross-hatched engraving around center of Mississippian cloud blower tube pipe from Tennessee.
Figure 5. Close-up of the double engraved rings at the center of the tube pipe decorated with cross-hatching.

Then, in February of 2020, at the Gallatin Tennessee artifact show, I once again got the honor of holding the “Stick Man Cloud Blower Tube Pipe.” This time I was able to acquire it. After 31 years had passed, I now get to enjoy the pipe that I always felt I would have found on that Thanksgiving Day in 1989.

The pipe was found near the Tennessee River at Clear Creek in Rhea County, Tennessee. It measures 6” in length, 1½” in width, and is 1¼” tall (Figs. 1, 2). It has two engraved figures on it and is said to depict male and female effigies (Figs. 3, 4). The middle has two rings around it with fine engraving on each of them (Fig. 5). The pipe is highly polished and a wonderful work of prehistoric art. I’m truly blessed to get to enjoy this pipe.

Colorful Ceramics from Arkansas and Missouri

Colorful Ceramics from Arkansas and Missouri July 1989 Central States Journal Vol, 36, Number 3, July, 1989

Colorful Ceramics from Arkansas and Missouri. Collection of Jack E Hall Moultrie Georgia.